“Even though there are no ways of knowing for sure, there are ways of knowing for pretty sure.”
Lemony Snicket
What does it mean to ‘know’ and how do we know we ‘know’?
The concept of’ knowing’, what it is that we ‘know’, and how we know we ‘know’ brings about questions when looking at this idea through the lens of a teacher. As outlined in Chapter Three of Finding Freedom in the Classroom: a Practical Introduction to Critical Theory by Patricia Hinchey, the concept of knowing can be looked at from two points of view, positivist or constructivist epistemology. Hinchey defines epistemology as “the branch of philosophy that seeks to define “knowledge”, that seeks to explain what it means to “know” something” (p. 35). Epistemology is important to consider in the classroom because the teacher-student relationship is rooted in the understanding of what ‘knowing’ something means.
Looking at knowledge as a positivist, knowledge is in a way a thing that can be grasped and found in the world. As Hinchey puts it “[k]nowledge is there, waiting for us to find it” (p. 36). Bringing positivism epistemology into the classroom connects to the vessel philosophy of learning in that students are empty vessels for students to fill with knowledge, as it is seen as a physical thing that can be attained. While this philosophy created harsh boundaries around what can be done in the classroom by both the teacher and the students, there is more to the positivistic point of view of what it is to ‘know’ something. When looking at the world as something that can be tested gives rise to different opinions of how the world works. Concepts and theories can be explored through inquiry and the scientific method. Positivism lends more to a scientific approach to learning and knowing while constructivism gives rise to more opinion based learning and knowing.
The constructivist epistemology looks at ‘knowing’ and learning as more of a link to the meaning of what is known. Hinchey defines it as something that “comes into being only when a human examines the data” (p. 41). This view of knowledge gives the power to the human race rather than to the surrounding world. This philosophy in the classroom gives more power to the students to suggest meaning out of the data that is collected. This does also play into the scientific way of thinking in the post data collection phase of the scientific method.
As a future educator, I had not really thought about what it meant to ‘know’ something. In my education experiences before coming to university and more so in university, ‘knowing something had to do with what and how much someone could remember and regurgitate onto an exam. The addition of this type of schooling and my home environment, which was full of science and math based conversation, the positivist understanding of what it is to ‘know’ something makes the most sense to me. The combination of my schooling and home environment may have been a catalyst in my gravitation towards the sciences and looking at things in a scientific fashion. Bringing these philosophies of what ‘knowing’ something means into the classroom re-orientates me as a teacher to seeing different possible ways of assessing students and creating learning moments.
Theories of Assessment
The relationship between assessment and learning is an important relationship to keep in mind as a teacher in order to know better how students learn and how to assess what they ‘know’. In James’ 2006 article Assessment, Teachering and Theories of Learning, she speaks about the alignment of assessment and learning, examples of assessment practices in the classroom, and three theories of learning. These theories include Behaviourist, Constructivist, and Socio-cultural.
The in behaviourist theory, learning comes from the “[r]ewards and punishments” and “[p]raise may be part of such a reward system” (James, 2006, p. 7). The implications of using this teaching and learning style int h classroom are that the teacher creates an atmosphere where the human consciousness is disregarded and there is no acknowledgement of the mind or intelligence (p. 7). This theory connects in a way to the positivist theory touched upon above in that it relies on students being correct or incorrect. The student knows something if they are able to give the ‘correct’ answer back to the teacher. The use of behaviourism as a teaching strategy causes assessment to look like timed tests and success is measured by correctness. The behaviourist approach limits the options of the teacher in the ways to assess students learning and understanding.
In Constructivist theory, which is a derivative of positivism, behaviourism, rationalism, and humanism, there is an emphasis on the students cognitive processes and there is a higher importance placed on the ‘understanding’ of the student. This theory calls for more “active engagement of learners and is determined by what goes on in people’s heads” (James, 2006, p.8). Bringing this type of teaching strategy into the classroom brings about more engagement in the students as well as potential for self-guided inquiry. The student plays a bigger role in their learning and in their assessment in that they are more active participants in the learning process. Assessment for this type fo theory looks more like self-reflection and opinion-based answers rather than straight regurgitation of content.
The socio-cultural theory is the interaction between the student and the social environment around them. James classifies thinking in this theory as being “constructed through actions that alter the situation and the situation changes the thinking” (p. 10). The thinking and the environment are constantly changing. James goes on to say that “it is difficult to judge an individual as acquired knowledge” under this theory (p. 10). In regard to assessment, this leaves the teacher in an awkward position in the classroom when there is a requirement of grades and some sort of record of the students knowledge or what they have learned.
Translation Into My Classroom
As a future teacher, these philosophies and theories impact my educational and assessment philosophy in how I look at students and the how they understand, my teaching, and how I will assess. There is no single theory that is best to use practically as a teacher, rather a mixing of the theories or a progression of one to another is needed to teach students and assess if they have actually learned anything. Positivism can be applied in the sense that there is adventure involved in the learning process. Society is on an adventure to find out more about the world and discovery answers to questions and educational institutions are attempting to given students the tools to venture forth to find out “why” and “how”. Once the data and information is found, the question is what does it mean? This is where the constructivist theory comes in. Applying meaning and context to the information that is gathered is important to finding out the answers to the questions that we have about the world around us. The teacher cannot rely on one process of assessing how a student knows something, we cannot be that narrow minded. Finding a middle ground or mixture of the way a teacher assess students keeps both the teacher and the students on their toes to see where both parties are at.
References
Hinchey, P. H. (2010). Finding freedom in the classroom: A practical introduction to critical theory (Vol. 24). Peter Lang.
James, M. (2006). Assessment, teaching and theories of learning. Assessment and learning, 47, 60.
References
Hinchey, P. (2010). CHAPTER THREE: Rethinking What We Know: Positivist and Constructivist Epistemology. Counterpoints,24, 33-55. Retrieved February 7, 2020, from www.jstor.org/stable/42976884
James, Mary. (2006). Assessment, Teaching and Theories of Learning. 10.13140/2.1.5090.8960.
Jessica Wiedemann
Jessica is a student at University of Regina. Her passion for helping others and advocacy for the prevention of bullying in schools has lead her to a career in education. She is a dog lover, photographer, and a food lover.
Make sure to comment below and follow her on social media, she loves to reach out and connect with you!